Mr Grumpy

Mr Grumpy

Western Thunderer
Looks like it needs more oil stains and the coupling are a bit on the bright side to me.
Thanks for your feedback Paul :)
I'm hoping to master the art of chemical blackening for the couplings, and will pick up the potion at the Reading show in December. I have cheated on several wagons by using a 'permanent black' pen, and several years on they are still black :thumbs:
As for the oil stains, I will revisit the bogies and buffer beam. I may add some water staining to the water tanks too :)
I accidently put a mighty scratch under the rad grille which I'm hoping to blend in later today.
 
Last edited:

Mr Grumpy

Western Thunderer
This build started on page 30 post#585 on 16th August (2016 for the cynics and comedians). An impressive result in a very short time. Well done!
Dave
Thanks Dave!
I guess when you open the box and you have two cabs, two sides a roof and chassis......:D
 

Heather Kay

Western Thunderer
Well, yes, I guess you are correct the end results look good. I just think I should be able to turn the stuff round a bit quicker than I currently manage.

Anyway, enough of me. What's next on the Grumpy workbench? :thumbs:
 

DougT

Western Thunderer
I thought I would post a photo of my 22 out in the rare glimpse of sunshine, before it is boxed away awaiting the arrival of my new layout.
Well Heather, it's a toss up between my AA3 toad and making a start on my Timber Tracks buildings....there's quite a few!

View attachment 59515
You have done a cracking job with this build, the detail and weathering are fantastic and really bring it to life. V. Impressed and inspired by both this and the Hymek. :)

On a slightly different tack, watching progress with this build has got me thinking more about the real locos, almost all of which were scrapped and gone long before I was born. Clearly I have no direct experience of them but they have to be one of the worst aesthetic (and engineering) designs ever to have graced the UK network. Someone made the comment on here about the design looking like the loco was dropped on its end during build, but you have to wonder whether the NBL design team, rather than knocking off the job to go to the pub half way through the design process, actually didn't bother starting it until they'd got back from the pub, bearing the back of a fag packet with some drawings on it, and then headed back on the pub before finishing. It's hard to imagine anyone being presented with the final drawings for approval saying "yes, that's exactly what a loco should look like, strong, fast, purposeful and attractive, let's build it"*. It's even harder to imagine anyone at BR responding with "Wow, now that is the very essence of a modernisation plan loco, reliable, strong, an amazing advert for British Rail, let's buy it".

Still, I guess it can be said that they have a charm of their own and beauty is in the eye of the beholder after all... Places tongue in cheek, puts coat on, legs it for the door. :D

*coincidentally, these are the very words that eminated from the Vulcan Foundry in late 1966 after the DP2 redesign team had finished their work...
 

Mr Grumpy

Western Thunderer
You have done a cracking job with this build, the detail and weathering are fantastic and really bring it to life. V. Impressed and inspired by both this and the Hymek. :)

On a slightly different tack, watching progress with this build has got me thinking more about the real locos, almost all of which were scrapped and gone long before I was born. Clearly I have no direct experience of them but they have to be one of the worst aesthetic (and engineering) designs ever to have graced the UK network. Someone made the comment on here about the design looking like the loco was dropped on its end during build, but you have to wonder whether the NBL design team, rather than knocking off the job to go to the pub half way through the design process, actually didn't bother starting it until they'd got back from the pub, bearing the back of a fag packet with some drawings on it, and then headed back on the pub before finishing. It's hard to imagine anyone being presented with the final drawings for approval saying "yes, that's exactly what a loco should look like, strong, fast, purposeful and attractive, let's build it"*. It's even harder to imagine anyone at BR responding with "Wow, now that is the very essence of a modernisation plan loco, reliable, strong, an amazing advert for British Rail, let's buy it".

Still, I guess it can be said that they have a charm of their own and beauty is in the eye of the beholder after all... Places tongue in cheek, puts coat on, legs it for the door. :D

*coincidentally, these are the very words that eminated from the Vulcan Foundry in late 1966 after the DP2 redesign team had finished their work...

One can only be thankful that even after extensive lobbying in Parliament, NBL failed to secure the contract to build the class 47!!
Looking at D600, you can imagine the dinasour that would have materialised:eek:
It's incredible that at the same time, forward thinking designers produced the athesicaly pleasing Hymek and Western :drool:
To be fair, I have liked the 22s since I used to see them rattling around in Cornwall when we holidayed there:)
 

Jordan

Mid-Western Thunderer
The weathering is really good; I do just wonder if any of them got into quite such a state whilst still in all-over green? How long was it from new until they were back in the works getting yellow end panels?
Just a thought - not intended as a nerd-like "er, I think you'll find..." type criticism. :oops:
 

Mr Grumpy

Western Thunderer
The weathering is really good; I do just wonder if any of them got into quite such a state whilst still in all-over green? How long was it from new until they were back in the works getting yellow end panels?
Just a thought - not intended as a nerd-like "er, I think you'll find..." type criticism. :oops:

Artistic licence :D

I don't normally put so much grime on the windscreen, but have a couple of photos (not mine) in all over green with the windscreen almost as bad as on my 22!
I think the coolant problem was there from the outset!
 

Jordan

Mid-Western Thunderer
Yeah, it was just a thought.
As it happens I wasn't thinking about the windscreens particularly - I'm well aware of how mucky a windscreen can get in a very short time!! :rolleyes: ;)
The reference to yellow panels was the thought that the rest of the loco might have got a clean-up or repaint at the same time as the panels were painted, but that might be assuming far too much..!!! :))
 

richard carr

Western Thunderer
I'm really glad you posted the photo of the real ones with horribly dirty windows as I was just about to say did they really have them that bad, but clearly they do.

It looks really good Richard, what are you doing next.

Richard
 

Mr Grumpy

Western Thunderer
I'm really glad you posted the photo of the real ones with horribly dirty windows as I was just about to say did they really have them that bad, but clearly they do.

It looks really good Richard, what are you doing next.

Richard

Hi Richard,
I rarely put so much grime on the windows, ( As on my Hymek) but as I said earlier, I wanted to portray the loco as a tad neglected. I have a couple of photos that are pretty much like I have done them!
My next item of rolling stock will be my AA3 Toad, but at the moment I'm building a Timber Tracks GWR parcel office.
It goes together quicker than a JLTRT kit :D
However, I think the time bandit will be in the painting.
 
Top