Embryo G1 Garden line
Simon said:
[quote=""Phill Dyson"":gxfema17]Nice to see yet more progress to your line Simon

, us garden modellers don't have layouts, we have proper lines :laugh: , you are putting yet more gauge one temptation in my path

:lol: . One quick question for you, what are the available alternatives for MK1 coaches in G1 apart from Fred's & the Tower brass ones ?
Cheers Phill
That is a very good question, if not the "sixty four thousand dollar question" for Gauge One.
There have been various kits of parts, but all in 10mm scale which is incorrect for the gauge (don't ask

)
In 1/32 there are Fred's kits and the Tower models, in addition to which various bespoke builders will custom build, but the costs are high in each case. The late David Jenkinson scratchbuilt coaches, but that is a huge amount of work requiring a lot of skill and patience.
There is/has been talk of either Accucraft (Ian Pearse) or Trevor Taylor (Gauge One Trains) getting RTR mk 1s made in Chine for the ?200 mark, which would be absolutely marvellous.
But then I look at the new Heljan O gauge offering and wonder whether such a model can ever be got right in the larger scales :scratch:
Personally, my aspirations are for a three coach set in Southern Region green with guests hopefully bringing additional stock to run on running days. This would give me an authentic "Withered Arm" train for my Class 22 and the SR/WR transition which so fascinates me.
Other projects and expense will mean this is some way away for me, although having seen how good Fred's coaches are I am tempted to try saving up and attempting one, but one wouldn't be enough and the amount of effort required is huge, by Fred's own admission :shock:
I also have various other prototype leanings (Prussian Blue) and the thought of live steam to run on my line too, so many distractions....
I love your layout and hope that any venture into G1 wouldn't jeapordize what you have done. Realistically speaking I am not sure that any of us could muster all the required elements to put on the "show" that you are already doing with your layout

[/quote:gxfema17]
Thanks for the kind words about my bodgings Simon

& don't worry I'm not about to call in Dr Beeching to the Withercombe branch :laugh: .......TBH the G1 seed was planted in my mind at last years Scalerail Bolton, I was drooling at the Tower stand & they had a O gauge painted & lined brass Black 5 at the side of a G1 painted & lined brass black 5 & there was something like ?150 difference in the prices

& the G1 one looked stunning to my eyes

, but I think you have confirmed what I already suspected with regard to the cost of rolling stock to go with the loco's & I would have to scale down my operation drastically in order to move up to G1, I do have the space ( I could double the size of my present line ) but without the likes of Lima & Triang to get me started I think it's probably a non starter really.............. for now :laugh:
Cheers Phill :wave: